View attachment 11583
You're talking about this, right?
I've often wondered about the inverted roll surround too. I haven't found a technical reason why it is superior...
So theoretically - a speaker is a piston. It moves in and out, not sideways.
I mention this because there have been thread after thread over the years discussing cone shape, dustcap shape (not counting phase plugs, which don't move) - and surround shape should follow:
Deep cone, shallow cone, flat piston, dome dustcap, dished dustcap, curved inverted dome cone with no dustcap, dome shape diaphragm... they theoretically all result in the same on-axis sound. And so it follows - the shape of the surround should follow those same points.
I qualify "theoretically" because Justin's comments on cone breakup cover some changes in sound that could result from both cone material
and geometry, so surround could also, although I'm sure much more slightly (although it can also dampen the cone, therefore change the cone breakup modes).
I qualify "on axis" because I've been deep-diving into the realm of omni-directional loudspeakers lately, which aren't used in cars (though I have an experiment in planning), and off-axis radiation can be different by shape, at least when you are talking about a dome shape that rises above the surround so off-axis sound isn't obstructed - or even inverting a speaker and listening to the back of it...
...not to get too off-track with that train of thought, but it makes me wonder if one benefit of the inverted surround would be to allow more of the off-axis sound energy to travel?
I'd also wonder if a surround could have a horn or edge effect, at higher frequencies anyway? Would a standard surround provide a slight horn effect? Would an inverted surround create a sharp edge that could cause a planned dip in the response (like a sharp edge on a baffle) at some frequency to compensate for over-efficiency somewhere?
Also, for subwoofers I've seen this used - I have to chalk it up as 100% "gimmick", there... although why not do something that looks cool, if it doesn't matter one way or the other? No harm, no foul there...
And definitely to your point, then yes, you might be able to fire a subwoofer into a loading panel or under a seat without the surround rubbing. Could be a real clearance advantage for a sub - although I'd have to worry about firing THAT close to a panel to begin with.
But for that little midrange - off-axis response maybe could be slightly extended? I don't know if you could even tell by looking at the response plots that overlay on-axis with off-axis plots of varying degrees, but it's a theory.
That does seem a little strange. I would enjoy hearing Andy's response if you ask him.
In general, the surround needs to be strong enough to withstand the air pressure and the mechanical forces on the cone. A larger cone is usually heavier so it might want a stronger surround (thicker), and a speaker with more travel will want a larger surround so it can move further. I don't think there is any magic there.
The discrepancy between two surrounds on two speakers with a similar xmax rating like you found could be a number of things. My first guess is the Xmax numbers might be calculated using a method that doesn't account for the performance of the surround such as looking at the voice coil overhang geometry alone. A performance-based Xmax measurement (like the IEC one I can't remember off the top of my head) might give different Xmax numbers. It's hard to say since I'm not sure what method was used.
Well, to be fair, we're talking about a 2.5" speaker compared to a 6x9 speaker here.
The expected frequency response of the 2.5" speaker - even being a wideband - is likely only going to be as low as like 300hz... 200hz, maybe 150hz if you really push it - and that matters for excursion.
Also - Xmax is usually going to be limited by the motor, when the voice coil starts exiting the magnetic gap.
That's of course different than Xmech, which is usually the point the suspension bottoms out physically.
I mention that because for a midrange, Xmax and Xmech could be very close, without any real risk to the driver - because of the intended use of the driver, not playing low (read: high excursion) frequencies.
(explained in the next paragraph)
On the other hand, for a 6x9 you might even use those as subwoofers. Some companies over the years have even made purpose-built 6x9 subwoofers (was it Infinity who made that crazy cool oval bandpass box with two isobaric pair of 6x9's in the '90s?). Even for regular 6x9's, you will probably want them reaching all the way down to your subwoofers... 80hz, 70hz, if you can. They are pretty comparable to eights, in terms of cone area and motor requirements... so, suspension as well.
Since for any given speaker, your excursion needs double for every octave lower you ask it to play, that 6x9 playing 80hz will need double the excursion of a 6x9 playing 160hz, and quadruple the excursion of that 6x9 playing 320hz.
So, since that 2.5" speaker isn't expected to play all that low, it shouldn't need as high-throw of a surround.
And on the flip side - a 2.5" speaker is a tiny cone. It's limitation to loudness is going to be "small cone area", so the designer may want to give it as large of a cone as possible - which could mean shrinking the surround. And if you don't need it for excursion - why not use a smaller surround to gain a touch more cone area and therefore efficiency?
In other cases though, where the frequency response of the drivers is more comparable, it could just be a matter of parts availability. A 6x9 likely has fewer parts available on the open market than say, a 6" or 8" round driver.
In that case, in the parts selection process, a desired cone and basket (two parts you WOULD want to scrutinize from an engineering standpoint) could be found that met the design goals for the 6x9, and a desired cone and basket that met the design goals for the 6" or 8" were found that met the same design goals... open market parts... and so they simply found a surround that worked to bridge the gap that was left, and allowed enough excursion.
Also, somewhere between 1/2 to 2/3 (depending on who you ask) of the surround counts as actual "cone area", because of the pistonic motion of the speaker, again... So having a wider surround isn't really that much of a penalty. If you could do one of those "all other variables being the same" experiments with an A/B comparison, a slightly wider surround wouldn't even be perceivable, I'm sure.
That's been discussed to death on all kinds of threads literally going back decades - starting way back when Audiobahn was using ludicrous, laughable "fat" surrounds... then Image Dynamics pioneered the tall/skinny surround alternative for long-throw with the IDmax...
My point here being that the surround width doesn't matter much until you get to extremes - "so fat" that it's silly, or "so skinny" that you actually are limiting excursion
for the desired frequency range.
Below the first bending mode frequency (which is 82.2hz in the video above) the material is not flexing or changing shape and so it will contribute very little extra content to the sound you are playing. For low frequencies such as subwoofers, this is mostly true...
To some extent, the material used will contribute to how a speaker sounds but mostly above the first bending mode frequency. One of the holy grails of audio is to get that first bending mode frequency above the audible range of music so that we can never hear the effects of cone breakup and this is one reason why exotic materials are desired like Beryllium and Graphene and Carbon Nanotechnology.
To make it even more complicated, every material in the speaker has banding modes and will contribute to the sound in one way or another. I've seen the same 2khz peak in frequency response in a number of speakers back at Eminence and it was caused by a very specific kind of voice coil configuration where the former was buzzing and you could hear in through the dust cap. The spider and surround and dust cap and even the basket will also have bending modes that can contribute to the sonic signature too. It's not just all about the cone material, well not always.
So this is a great topic (in my exceptionally geeky technical opinion) for a deep dive... especially since I'm speaker shopping myself, right now - and I always advocate "always listen before buying!", while secretly resenting that there aren't specs and properties to use while shopping to narrow down the list of speakers to give a listen to. Or, in my case - I have several speakers on my list that I simply can't listen to... but man, they'd be great bang-for-the-buck if they sound as good as their specs seem to otherwise imply a perfect fit for my specific needs.
Is there a general list or study or test result, of cone materials [even understanding there's going to be some variance possible from one vendor to the other - all aluminum cones aren't the same, all paper cones aren't the same, etc] or even a forum thread somewhere... just to at least give a general clue, showing what frequencies that even those first bending modes occur at?
For example, if aluminum *generally* has a higher first bending mode frequency than paper, and I'm looking to push my tweeter crossover point up higher for some installation design target - it might help to know "you might want to look into aluminum cone mids (along with whatever other materials might have 'higher than paper' bending mode frequencies). Does such a list exist?