Originally Posted by
Smitty
For any new guy reading this... do NOT believe that a simple measurement will magically allow you to model cabin gain in WinISD. The only way I know how to truly determine cabin gain is to take a subwoofer and measure its anechoic response. Then place it in the vehicle and measure the in-car response. What I did was simply apply a 12db per octave filter beginning at the frequency the measurement suggested. In this example it is 65.82 Hz. It does not take into account what amount of CLD you have, thinner sheet metal on newer vehicles with the same dimensions, altitude, humidity, etc... This only gives a theoretical idea of where you may be. The few times I've measured actual cabin gain, it did not look like the model. It may roughly resemble the higher end but it usually peaks and has more of a shelf response after the peak and some things that need to be eq'd out. Keep in mind the tuning changes when you open a window. Technically, driving from the beach to the mountains changes the subs response. I personally do not get wrapped up in the numbers, especially predicted db. I just look at the shape of the curves and look for nasty surprises. Over the years I have learned which curves/response profiles I prefer.
Regarding the case at hand, I modeled the ID sub and found their recommendations to be well done. Go figure, right? I personally would prefer the 0.8 ft3, maybe slightly larger. The power handling will begin to drop in the low frequencies as you go larger than 1.3 ft3. At 1.5 ft3 the power handling is predicted to be around 225 watts at 20 Hz. Do not stress about this as you will not be in this range. I say grab the subs, throw them in the box and jam out. I think you'll like the sound. If you want to tweak it some, that is easy. Just give us your feedback and we'll help you out. Making the box smaller is simply just cutting a block the size of the volume you want to decrease and screw it somewhere inside the box. I think the grills queef suggested should work fine.